So far, we have seen what goals do, but we have omitted to mention what happens to people when they do not set goals in their lives.
Indecision, lack of focus, boredom, and not having something specific to strive for, can lead to a feeling that one is living a dulled, less meaningful version of their life. Symptoms of depression, among other mental health struggles, often appear in these perceived unchanging spaces.
This is because specifically-written goals can provide individuals with a sense of existential structure, purpose, and meaning.
As Locke argues, goals are “immediate regulators of behavior” (Latham, Ganegoda, & Locke, 2011), and they provide the self with a vision for the future and a clear direction to strive towards a specific objective.
More so, goal-directed action coupled with reasoning skills is a fundamental element of what makes us human. Even the “non-human” world thrives with goal-setting parallels.
This is not to say that plants write down their goals in pencil. But let’s have Locke explain how:
“The lowest level of goal-directed action is physiologically controlled (plants). The next level, present in the lower animals, entails conscious self-regulation through sensory-perceptual mechanisms including pleasure and pain. Human beings possess a higher form of consciousness – the capacity to reason. They have the power to conceptualize goals and set long-range purposes”
(Locke, 1969).
The human ability to reflect is a curse and a blessing.
It liberates us from the constraint of the absolute determinism of things but it also means that we are responsible for the choices we make and whether they will contribute to our welfare.
For instance, individuals who start exercising and feeling the numerous health benefits often end up seeing value in making additional lifestyle changes, such as a healthier routine and diet.
Thus, if a goal is perceived by the individual as something that can contribute to their sense of wellbeing or that of the group they are a part of, then it can also serve as a source of inspiration and esteem.
This often leads to a ricochet effect on other behaviors linked to performance and efficacy.
Can Goal-Setting Help Decision-Making?
Goal-setting and decision making are the two voluntary acts that can radically transform a person’s life.
You perhaps have heard the adage, “you cannot save someone who doesn’t want to be saved.”
When it comes to helping others, it is not possible to do so unless they want the help, and also feel enough motivation to take the appropriate steps forward—regardless of how tiring this may prove.
Setting goals empower decision making, and the opposite is true as well. It enables people to filter through what is significant, worth pursuing and what is not.
Goal-Setting vs. Expectancy Theory
Expectancy theory was developed by Victor Vroom (1964) and looks at the mental processes which underlie motivation and choice-making.
Vroom outlines three main factors which structure how humans decide to go about their lives and the steps needed to achieve a given result: expectancy, instrumentality, and valence.
He argues that ‘motivational force’ can be calculated by means of multiplying expectancy with instrumentality and valence.
The actual formula looks like this:
Motivational force = Expectancy x Instrumentality x Valence
Put in a literary way, Vroom’s point is that motivation emerges from a person’s belief that an invested effort will enable them to achieve a certain desired performance, and that the way this performance is played out, will lead to the fulfillment of a specific goal.
In turn, the extent to which the individual perceived this final goal as desirable (valence) will also shape the degree of motivation for the individual to pursue a given goal.
In other words, confidence, assessment of what is required, and the value perceived on the specific outcome equal the energy an individual may feel towards a specific goal.
Expectancy theory adds an interesting dimension to Locke’s goal-setting theory. Locke provides insight into which goals are implemented in effective ways. Vroom, on the other hand, sheds light on how self-esteem, individual perception and the value system of individuals come into play.
The theories coined by Locke and Vroom do intersect in how they emphasize the importance of setting goals that are tailored to subjective needs and capacities.
To spark the necessary ‘motivational force’ for any given challenge, there must be momentum. With this momentum come success, especially when failure is encouraged as part of the learning process.
9 Excellent Journal Articles for Further Reading
One of the great aspects of goal-setting is that it is applicable in most domains of life.
For more detail regarding the different studies mentioned, you can find the original sources in the bibliography. It is possible to find information related to goal-setting on practically every subject.
For example, if you have specific goals to becoming a published writer, there are plenty of step-by-step guides offered on the internet.
There is also a wealth of literature documenting the benefits of goal-setting in the context of workplaces, especially since the theory began as an attempt to enhance employee motivation in the workplace.
For your convenience, we compiled a list of recently published journal articles relating to goal-setting, applied to a range of contexts.
If you don’t have access to academic material and would like to consult on any of the following articles, don’t hesitate to drop us a message.
Goal-setting in the Professional World:
- Exercise Self-Efficacy as a Mediator between Goal-Setting and Physical Activity: Developing the Workplace as a Setting for Promoting Physical Activity by Iwasaki et al. (2017)
- Achievement Goal Orientation and its Implications for Workplace Goal-Setting Programs, Supervisory/Subordinate Relationships and Training by Rysavy (Dissertation, 2015)
- Experiential Exercises on Goal-Setting, Leadership/Followership, and Workplace Readiness (Ritter, 2015)
Goal-setting with Students/Adolescents:
- What is the effect of peer-monitored Fitnessgram testing and personal goal-setting on performance scores with Hispanic middle school students? (Coleman, 2017)
- Effect of Student SMART Goal-Setting in a Low-Performing Middle School (Thomas, 2015)
- Does Participation in Organized Sports Influence School Performance, Mental Health, and/or Long-Term Goal-Setting in Adolescents? (Samarasinghe, Khan, Mccabe, Lee, 2017)
Goal-setting in Healthcare/ with Patients:
- Goal-setting in neurorehabilitation: development of a patient-centered tool with theoretical underpinnings (Aleksandrowicz, 2016)
- Rehabilitation goal-setting: theory, practice, and evidence (Siegert & Levack, 2015)
- Evaluating the Structure of the Patient Assessment of Chronic Illness Care (PACIC) Survey from the Patient’s Perspective (Fan et al., 2015)
A Nuanced Perspective
Goals, goals, goals.
Staying informed with how to improve oneself and others is important; however, too much absorption with the topic may overlook the very value of existence.
It’s not enough to be busy, so are the ants. The question is, what are we busy about?
Henry David Thoreau
Thoreau’s excellent words invite us to reflect on the broader picture. Do our goals push us to pursue really matters? If so, then continue. If not, perhaps it is time to pause.
Even though goal-setting can indeed strengthen a person’s sense of purpose, self-confidence, and autonomy, the habit of setting goals can lead us astray from our core values.
The current trend, unfortunately, is following this “busy route” where burnout is ingrained with modern corporate culture (Petersen, 2019). It is especially affecting the millennial generation.
As Petersen’s (ibid) article shows, it can be hard enough to perform the most basic tasks, such as answering emails, doing household chores, registering to vote, calling people on their birthdays, etc.
Burnout, Petersen argues, is part of the over-involvement of baby-boomer parents in their children’s lives, as well as the shifting of modern labor relations and social media technologies.
In many ways, this has blurred the line that used to exist between professional and private life, that is largely nonexistent now.
Many people feel pressure to always brand or market who they are or what they do so that they can feel connected and compete for social status, even when not in the professional world. For many, this shows as the internalization of a feeling that one should be working ‘all the time.’
This pushes people to compare their lives or ‘impact’ with others and make goals out of social comparison and insecurity, rather than goals centered from a genuine desire to change something.
A culture of self-care has arisen, as a possible response to burnout and overwhelming times.
Self-care, however, is not a complete solution given that:
“the problem with holistic, all-consuming burnout is that there’s no solution to it. You can’t optimize it to make it end faster. You can’t see it coming like a cold and start taking the burnout-prevention version of Airborne. The best way to treat it is to first acknowledge it for what it is — not a passing ailment, but a chronic disease — and to understand its roots and its parameters.”
Peterson also recalls the words of the social psychologist Devon Price, who, writing on the topic of homelessness, argued that:
“Laziness, at least in the way most of us generally conceive of it, simply does not exist. If a person’s behavior does not make sense to you, it is because you are missing a part of their context. It’s that simple.”
Hence, this comes as a cautionary message against excessive goal-setting and the madness of constant self-development and improvement.
Modern society encourages us to feel that we are never “good enough.” How do we balance the self-compassion that we are enough, with the desire to be better and set goals?
Perhaps one answer is to avoid goals that do not align with your core values, as well as goals that do more harm than good.
On the same note, Ordonez, Schweitzer, Galinsky, and Bazerman (2009) warn about what happens when ‘goals go wild:’ when goals are too narrow, too challenging, too numerous and enacted within an unrealistic timeframe, they can lead to disastrous consequences.
These consequences range from unethical behavior to psychological pitfalls linked with experiencing failure. For example, if a company boss aims to increase profits by over-working and underpaying staff, this is not a sustainable or ethical goal for anyone involved.
The authors, basing on management studies, also reveal how goal-setting may come at the expense of learning. Again, how do we avoid feeding a competitive culture, and instead, promote cultures of growth and intrinsic motivation?
To avoid this, Steve Kerr from General Electric advises managers to refrain from setting goals that are likely to increase their employees’ stress levels or contain punishing failure; instead, Kerr wants to equip staff with the necessary tools to meet the challenging goals.
This approach, Ordonez et al. argue, will encourage managers to consider whether the goal-setting culture benefits the company’s outputs and the wellbeing of their employees.
Locke & Latham (2002) also warned about the potential pitfalls of combining goals with financial rewards in the workplace; this usually brings employers to set rather easy goals as opposed to more challenging ones instead.
Before rushing to set personal or business goals, it is important to consider your motivation.
What our readers think
BTW the A in SMART is Assignable… Not achievable.
Achievable and Realistic are the same.
Hi,
This was wonderful. Reading this article was enjoyable with full understanding. I didn’t know what to do but I have got a full concept on goal-setting of which i am ready to write about it . Thank you so much.
Great article – I’ve just read it as I am composing my own article on goal setting. There is a lot of really useful information on here and you have managed to condense a lot of information into key messages. The nuanced point really resonated, I am writing about exactly that topic. I have a site which is to help people with self-development and overall well-being and I myself have to work out how to get the balance right between self-development and savouring life/living in the present so it’s good to see it also mentioned here. I will link to this article on my site and bring through some of the key messages to reinforce some of my own.
Great article! So much detail, knowledge, and inspiration in this article. Enjoyed reading it!