Growth Mindset vs Fixed Mindset
“Individuals who believe their talents can be developed (through hard work, good strategies, and input from others) have a growth mindset” (Dweck, 2016). On the other hand, those with a fixed mindset believe such talents are an innate gift and not easily changed.
While Carol Dweck’s pioneering work on the growth mindset has had a considerable impact since her 2014 TED Talk and more recent book Mindset, it is often misunderstood.
Therefore, it is essential to be clear on exactly what a growth mindset is and avoid some of the common misconceptions that arise, including (Dweck, 2016):
- I’ve always had it.
A false growth mindset often results from confusing the concept with flexibility or open-mindedness. We are all a mixture of fixed and growth mindsets; we can’t claim to have always had one or the other.
- It’s just about praising effort.
While effort is essential, it must be productive. Deep engagement in the processes that lead to positive outcomes is vital, such as trying out new strategies, asking for help, and learning from failure.
- Talking about a growth mindset is enough.
Adopting a growth mindset means more than saying it’s a great outlook to have. Organizations, in particular, need to encourage staff to take appropriate risks, support collaboration over competition, and facilitate learning and development.
To enter or remain in the growth zone, we must recognize fixed mindset triggers we find in the environment that hold us back. It could be fear of failure or uncertainty over competence. Once we recognize what makes us feel defensive or threatened, we can challenge and even talk back to it (Dweck, 2016).
As Angela Duckworth (2018, p. 180) notes, “some of us believe, deep down, that people really can change.” That’s a growth mindset.
Growth-minded individuals believe that we can get smarter with the right opportunities, degree of effort, and self-belief. Those who are more fixed in their outlook agree that you can learn skills (e.g., fixing a car, riding a bike, etc.) but believe you can’t train your talent.
A setback for someone with a fixed mindset can be catastrophic, believing they don’t have what it takes, while someone with a growth mindset sees it as a chance to learn and get better (Duckworth, 2018).
Research Behind the Theory and Model
While Dweck’s ideas on the importance of adopting a growth mindset have been widely accepted and applauded, sometimes without fully grasping the importance of the principles beneath, it is vital to remember that it is more than just an idea.
Dweck and others have spent years researching what a growth mindset is and is not, and their findings back up their claims (Dweck, 2017).
In a 2013 study, Gunderson et al. found that praising effort in children leads to a growth mindset, while encouraging inherent abilities leads to adopting fixed-ability frameworks. Ongoing research has identified that adopting a growth mindset dramatically changes how you approach life and encourages success in education, business, and even relationships (Dweck, 2017).
Yeager and Dweck (2020) explained the current state of research into growth mindsets in education and attempted to answer some of the challenges and questions surrounding the theory. Some examples from their research are included below.
1. Does a growth mindset predict academic outcomes?
Mostly. “There is a replicable and generalizable association between mindsets and achievement” (Yeager & Dweck, 2020, p. 5).
A fixed mindset typically predicts lower academic results in tests and exams compared with a growth mindset. However, findings suggest that it may not have an effect when hours of study are very high, such as in Mainland China, with a reported 57 hours of study per week.
2. Do growth mindset interventions work?
Not always. While growth interventions (for example, encouraging effort, seeking help, and changing strategies) sometimes improve academic success, that is not always the case. Outcomes vary depending on the individual’s psychological profile and the type of interventions used.
It appears that finding a growth mindset intervention appropriate to the individual and their needs is crucial.
3. Can teachers instill a growth mindset in their students?
Unclear. Mindset interventions either aimed at or administered by teachers at scale have not generally proved successful. Despite immense care and effort, positive results have not been immediate. And yet, benefits may be seen in the longer term.
It seems positive results are more likely in response to direct-to-student programs that teach students a growth mindset directly.
While inconclusive, there appears to be a theme rising from the research. Adopting a growth mindset is not a silver bullet, always guaranteeing better performance and improved outcomes. Yet, when an intervention is well timed and appropriate to the individual, a shift in mindset becomes apparent, leading to success in multiple areas of life (Dweck, 2017).
What our readers think
Thank you very much for your insightful article and resources.
You are a point of reference and inspiration for me 🙂
Good day, PositivePsychology.com!
I just want to ask if the “Mindset Survey” by Lucinda Poole listed in your website free to use for undergraduate research? If not, I appreciate any information about individuals or organizations I can contact about the rights to use of the materials.
Thank you very much!
Hi Jaehyun,
Thank you for reaching out! Could you just let me know which worksheet you are referring to? In general, you are more than welcome to use our free tools in undergraduate research. More so, we would love to hear about how you are planning to implement it 🙂
Warmly,
Julia | Community Manager
Thank you for the overview and resources. The information you provided is helpful. I would point out that the examples of dilemmas may not be dilemmas. That question led me to consider whether the issue of growth mindset should be considered only in the context of dilemmas, but I think not. I also wonder if a growth mindset is a necessary component to achievement. I don’t have an instinct for an answer to that one. Cheers!
Hi Robert,
Thank you for taking the time to read and engage with the article! We appreciate your insights and the thoughtfulness you put into your comment.
You made an interesting observation about dilemmas, highlighting the versatility of a growth mindset in various life aspects. Regarding its necessity for achievement, a growth mindset is beneficial but not solely responsible, as factors like motivation, resources, and environmental support are also vital.
We encourage you to keep exploring these ideas! If you have any more thoughts or questions, please don’t hesitate to share.
Kind regards,
Julia | Community Manager
This article was truly helpful as it helped me know my mindset.
Thanks a lot….
This is truly helpful, may God bless the writer